Which Coding Agent Fits Your Actual Job?

Use one repository fixture to compare Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, and GitHub Copilot. Rule out execution paths that miss the job's architecture or control requirements before comparing how quickly reviewers can verify the result.

Put an architecture assertion in the fixture

Cursor documents x86-64 for its managed Cloud Agent VMs and supports running tool calls on your own ARM64 hardware through My Machines or Team Pools. Its agent loop still runs in Cursor's cloud. For an ARM64 job, make the fixture compile and execute a tiny native test, then record the runner architecture and the test's exit status in the review artifact. A patch that passes a cross-compile alone leaves the runtime requirement unverified. For a job that must keep its checkout on equipment you control, have the operator record the worker identity separately from the build result. Run the same fixture for any other candidate and record where its tools actually ran. This gives the reviewer two independent facts to check even when candidates produce identical diffs.

Choose where Cloud Agents run | Cursor Docs

Separate a clean diff from a repeatable review

GitHub documents Copilot CLI and the Copilot cloud agent as distinct surfaces with different eligibility rules. Include the exact surface in the trial name, and check that the fixture repository is eligible before timing a GitHub-hosted run. Seed the fixture with one benign failing regression and one unrelated file that should remain unchanged. Give every path the same instruction and have an independent reviewer inspect the proposed patch, confirm that it touches only the expected files, and rerun the regression in a clean checkout. Record the time from submission until the reviewer can open both the diff and the test evidence. For Claude Code or Codex in a terminal, capture those same outputs through your chosen review handoff. A fast terminal completion with evidence still trapped in the initiating session will show up as a failed handoff.

Agent skills - GitHub Docs

Compare the terminal and delegated paths

Pair Claude Code and Codex CLI on one terminal-led task. Give both the same repository revision, failing test, and acceptance checks. Confirm that the developer can inspect the commands, review the resulting diff, and rerun the relevant test. Score the number of times the developer has to intervene to finish the task. OpenAI documents that Codex CLI runs locally and identifies Codex Web as its cloud-based agent.

For an illustrative trial, give both agents a parser bug with two failing tests and require those tests to pass without modifying unrelated files. Then try the same brief in Codex Web. Have a reviewer open the result after the submitter disconnects and check whether they can inspect the diff and reproduce the test result. Record these as separate terminal and delegation outcomes.

GitHub - openai/codex: Lightweight coding agent that runs in your terminal · GitHub

Pick the Cursor execution boundary

For an editor-led task, trial Cursor with a developer reviewing edits as they happen. Record whether the developer can narrow the scope, inspect the diff, and run the same acceptance tests used for the terminal trial. For delegated work, compare Cursor-hosted Cloud Agents with Self-Hosted Machines. Cursor documents isolated managed VMs for the hosted path and tool execution on your hardware for the self-hosted path. The agent loop stays in Cursor's cloud in both cases.

If repository checkout and tool execution must stay on your hardware, run a self-hosted pilot and check where the checkout and test process actually appear. If policy also requires the agent loop to run on your hardware, exclude that option. For an otherwise eligible pilot, test worker availability by taking one designated test machine offline and checking whether jobs finish or fail visibly.

Choose where Cloud Agents run | Cursor Docs

Prove the GitHub issue handoff

Try GitHub Copilot cloud agent when the desired handoff starts in GitHub and ends with a reviewable change. GitHub's documentation lists availability on paid Copilot plans and describes repository exceptions. Confirm eligibility, repository policy, and the issue assignment path in a pilot repository before committing to this workflow.

Create a small issue with a reproducible failure, a list of allowed files, and a named test. Verify that a reviewer can trace the proposed change back to the issue, inspect the diff, and reproduce the test result without a private prompt history. If assignment is unavailable, check repository eligibility and whether the agent has been disabled. If the job runs but produces no usable review artifact, tighten the issue's acceptance criteria and repeat the same test on a terminal or cloud candidate.

Agent skills - GitHub Docs

Sources