Which Part of Claude Managed Agents Should You Replace?

Use a self-hosted Claude Managed Agents worker when execution location is the constraint. Evaluate the Claude Agent SDK on infrastructure you operate or on Amazon Bedrock AgentCore Runtime when you need to deploy and control the agent application.

Test the boundary with a synthetic tool result

Separate the location of the workspace from the location of the agent loop. A self-hosted Claude Managed Agents worker runs bash and file operations on your infrastructure, while Anthropic still selects tool calls and receives their results. The environment guide also says Anthropic connects to the agent’s MCP servers, so a private endpoint reachable by the worker does not prove MCP connectivity. Create a synthetic record with two fields, such as `status=ready` and `internal_marker=CANARY-17`. Have a worker-served tool return only the status, then inspect the result at your application boundary. Repeat with an error path, where an exception might include the whole record. If the policy permits status to leave and the marker stays inside, compare the worker against that exact contract. If the loop itself must run under your control, test an application you deploy.

Choosing an agent environment - Claude Platform Docs

Recover a job after its acknowledgment disappears

Amazon Bedrock AgentCore Instances runs the agent application on managed EC2 capacity in your AWS account and handles instance lifecycle operations. Compare that arrangement with a Claude Agent SDK application on infrastructure you operate by running the same interruption drill against both. Give each invocation a stable job ID and use a test tool whose only effect is recording a receipt in a test ledger. After the receipt commits, simulate a dropped acknowledgment in the fixture and retry with the same ID. Capture elapsed time from interruption to confirmed completion, the number of receipts for the ID, and whether every intended job completed. A 12-second recovery with two receipts fails a one-receipt contract. Include a control trial that drops the request before commit, since an implementation that simply suppresses every retry can pass the duplicate check while silently losing work.

Instances - Amazon Bedrock AgentCore

Keep the loop if private tool access is enough

Claude Managed Agents offers an Anthropic cloud environment and a self-hosted sandbox. In the self-hosted option, your worker executes tool calls while Claude on Anthropic's side decides which tool to call next. Use this option when a tool must reach a private service and you can allow the model to receive the tool's output. List the fields that may leave your environment before you connect a real data source.

For an illustrative pilot, assume an internal inventory service returns a synthetic SKU, an availability count, and a private supplier note. Expose only the SKU and count to the model. Check that the worker can reach the private service, that the answer uses the correct count, and that the note is absent from the tool result sent upstream. If policy bars even the permitted fields from leaving, this deployment fails the data boundary.

Choosing an agent environment - Claude Platform Docs

Compare runtime ownership with one recovery drill

Amazon Bedrock AgentCore Runtime on Instances hosts your agent or tool code on EC2 managed instances within your AWS account. AWS handles instance provisioning, patching, scaling, and teardown. Use it as a candidate when you want to deploy your own agent code and delegate instance operations. Compare it with a self-hosted Claude Agent SDK application when your team wants to own the application and its deployment environment. Verify model access for the exact region and account you plan to use.

Run the same two-turn task on each candidate. Have the first turn create a test artifact and the second retrieve it after a deployment restart. Record whether the expected session and file return, where the state lives, and who can diagnose a failed restore. Include Google Gemini Enterprise Agent Platform or Azure Foundry Agent Service only after confirming the required model, runtime interface, and state behavior in their official documentation.

Instances - Amazon Bedrock AgentCore

Replace the harness only if you need to control it

Anthropic describes the Claude Agent SDK as the harness behind Claude Code adapted for other kinds of agents. Use it as a candidate if you want to build the application around that harness. If the requirement is to change how the loop selects models, carries context, or schedules tool calls, put a harness you can modify on the shortlist. For TrueForge or OpenClaw, verify the specific loop controls and integration interfaces before assigning either a role in the migration.

Build a test set from representative tasks and hold input data, permissions, and success criteria constant. If both candidates support the same model, use it to make differences in harness behavior easier to interpret. Record correct outcomes, tool calls, retries, and token usage. Include one interruption after a tool succeeds, then verify that resuming the task does not silently repeat the operation.

Building agents with the Claude Agent SDK | Claude by Anthropic

Sources