Trial Evidence Evaluator
6 items active
Prosecution Burden & Presumption
85% Req.
Reasonable Doubt Standard
85% Certainty
Standard: Firmly convinced of guilt. If certainty is below this line, verdict must be Not Guilty.
Admitted Exhibits & Testimonies
* Adjusting probative value and witness credibility dynamically re-computes the timeline likelihood ratio and jury verdict probability.
Forensic Chronology & Discrepancy Map T-0 to T+45m
Prosecution Theory
Defense / 911 Call
Discrepancy
Hover over any timeline marker to inspect time offsets, witness corroboration, and forensic conflicts.
Jury Deliberation Certainty Gauge
REASONABLE DOUBT PREVAILSThreshold: 85%
0% (Presumption of Innocence)
Prosecution Score: 78.4%
100% (Moral Certainty)
The prosecution’s circumstantial evidence (including conflicting 911 dispatch timestamps and smart-lock logs) points strongly to the defendant, but currently sits 6.6% below the required reasonable doubt threshold (85%). Under Ohio jury instructions, an acquittal or hung jury is legally required until the physical timeline discrepancy is reconciled.
Telemetry synchronized with 6 admitted trial exhibits.
Ohio Criminal Jury Instruction § CR 409.01
"Reasonable doubt is present when, after you have carefully considered and compared all the evidence, you cannot say you are firmly convinced of the truth of the charge. It is a doubt based on reason and common sense."
- Burden of Proof: Remains strictly upon the State throughout trial; never shifts to the defendant.
- Staged Crime Scene Claims: When the defense posits a third-party intruder, the State must disprove the intruder hypothesis beyond a reasonable doubt through corroborating physical timeline evidence.
- Circumstantial Inferences: Inferences must be based on proven facts rather than stacking inferences upon other inferences.
Forensic Timeline Methodology
This workbench cross-examines subjective witness testimony with hard digital forensics:
- PSAP / 911 Audio Capture: Precise CAD (Computer Aided Dispatch) audio waveform markers, ringback durations, and operator pick-up timestamps.
- IoT & Security Sensors: Magnetic reed door switches, motion sensor infrared logs, and vehicle telematics vs claimed intruder ingress.
- Gunshot Acoustic / Ballistics: Distance estimation from stippling/tattooing, shell casing ejection corridors, and firearm registry corroboration.