MLB Network Radio Analyst Lab

NL MVP Matrix: Ohtani Pitching Return vs PCA Dual-Threat Workbench

Jac Caglianone on SiriusXM: "If Ohtani comes back and pitches it's going to be hard not to lean on his side. What Pete's doing is unreal."
LAD #17 Shohei Ohtani
DH / RHP
Offensive WAR
6.8
Mound Pitch WAR
+0.0
Total Two-Way bWAR
6.8
44 HR | 35 SB | 178 wRC+
Model Decision Matrix Result
Shohei Ohtani holds +0.8 WAR Advantage
Baseline DH production outpaces elite defense prior to mound return.
+0.8 WAR
5-Tool & Two-Way Skill Radar
Ohtani PCA
WAR Trajectory & Decomposition
Ohtani Total PCA Total
Sabermetric Comparison Grid
Component Metric Shohei Ohtani Pete Crow-Armstrong Advantage
CHC #52 Pete Crow-Armstrong
CF / Platinum Glove
Offensive WAR
3.2
Defensive WAR
2.8
Total Position Player bWAR
6.0
22 HR | 42 SB | +18 DRS | +16 OAA
💡 Voter Weighting Dynamic: Increasing defensive valuation to 1.40x elevates PCA to 6.5 WAR. When Ohtani adds even 15+ IP (~1.1+ pWAR), his two-way ceiling extends beyond 7.9 WAR.
Enjoy this tool? Build your own with Super