Rental vs Equities Reality Engine

Deconstructing Passive Income: Real Estate vs Equities & REITs

Market Presets:
Executive Reality Check

Rental Cash Flow vs Passive Dividends

Initial Capital $100,000
Time Horizon 15 Years

Real estate achieves higher total wealth growth via 4x leverage if property appreciation matches 3.5%, but stocks yield virtually identical passive net annual cash flow in Year 1 with zero landlord time requirements.

Rental Net Cash Flow (Yr 1)
$3,624 3.62% CoC

After debt, tax, ins, maint & mgmt

Equities Dividend Yield
$2,800 9.25% Net Total

100% passive, zero operational labor

Liquid REIT Benchmark
$4,200 4.20% Yield

Real estate yield without direct title

Effective Landlord Wage
$50.33/hr $38.50/hr B/E

At 6 hrs/mo active oversight

Annual Cash Flow Waterfall Decomposition

Where does gross rental income actually go before reaching your pocket?

Year 1 Net Yield
Line Item Component Annual Impact Monthly Impact % Gross Rent

Total Net Equity Compounding

Real Estate (Leveraged Equity) vs Stocks vs REITs

Year 15 Real Estate Net Equity: $0
Year 15 Equities Portfolio (Compounded): $0
Year 15 REIT Portfolio: $0

Diligence Parameters & Sensitivity Sliders

Stress-test real estate friction, interest rates, vacancy spikes, and active landlord hours.

Live Recalculation Active

Real Estate Financing

Property Purchase Price $400,000
Down Payment % 25% ($100,000)
Mortgage Interest Rate 6.5%
Gross Monthly Rent $2,800/mo

Operating Frictions & Drag

Vacancy Rate 5.0%
Property Management Fee 8.0%
Property Tax Rate (% value) 1.2%
Landlord Labor (Hours / Mo) 6 hrs/mo

Equities & Long-Term Drivers

Stock Dividend Yield 2.8%
Stock Capital Growth Rate 6.5%
Real Estate Appreciation Rate 3.5%
Analysis Horizon (Years) 15 Years

Structured Due Diligence Framework: When to Choose Which

🏆 Real Estate Wins When:
  • You acquire in growing tier cities with rapid population & job expansion.
  • You can lock in sustainable fixed-rate mortgage leverage (3x-4x).
  • Depreciation & 1031 exchanges shield taxable ordinary income.
  • You have local operational bandwidth for turnover & repairs.
Equities / ETFs Win When:
  • Your primary job or life values 100% passive, zero-friction capital.
  • Immediate liquidity is essential (instant settlement vs 60-day sale).
  • You avoid geographical concentration risk and municipal tax hikes.
  • Tenant dispute, eviction moratoria, and property liability are unacceptable.
🏢 Public REITs Win When:
  • You demand institutional-grade commercial property exposure.
  • High upfront dividend yield (4.0% - 6.0%) is required immediately.
  • Professional management is baked into share prices without active hours.
  • Zero personal loan guarantees or foreclosure exposure.
Enjoy this tool? Build your own with Super