NFL ON CBS ANALYTICS EXECUTIVE QB STRATEGY LAB

NFL QB Sit vs. Start Developmental Decision Matrix

Inspired by Amy Trask’s roster management philosophy: Evaluating protection thresholds & developmental value

“I like the decision to sit [Fernando Mendoza].” — @AmyTrask

Game-Day Parameters

LIVE MODEL
OL Pass Protection Grade (PFF Scale) 54.2
Threshold: <58 creates severe mechanical regression in young QBs
Opponent Defensive Blitz Rate 38.5%
High blitz vs shaky OL accelerates time-to-pressure (<2.2s)
QB Mental Processing / Readiness 68 / 100
Game Leverage Index (Context) 1.15x
Front-Office Strategy Recommendation
Sit / Protect
Sit / Protect
Trask Consensus:
86

Aggressive opponent blitz front + sub-58 pass protection triggers structural protection mandate.

Tactical Pocket Collapse & Pressure Zones EST. TIME TO PRESSURE: 2.18s (CRITICAL)
QB SIT & PROTECT
Dev Preservation Index
High (82/100)
Mechanics and pocket composure safeguarded
Turnover Risk Avoidance
+24.8%
Reduction in turnover-worthy plays vs blitz
Executive Consensus Score
86 / 100
Agreement with Amy Trask sit strategy
Comparable Historical Cohort
Cohort B (Sit-and-Develop)
Patrick Mahomes, Jordan Love archetype
Executive Football Rationale (Trask Framework)

With an offensive line pass-blocking grade of 54.2 against a 38.5% blitz rate, exposing young signal-caller Fernando Mendoza to live reps risks developing defensive-ghost syndrome, broken footwork, and turnover spikes. Sitting now preserves long-term franchise capital.

Historical QB Precedents

Empirical comparison of early career development approaches under comparable OL support tiers.

Quarterback Year 1 Plan OL Tier Year 3 Passer Rtg
P. Mahomes Sat 15 Gms Top 12 105.3
J. Love Sat 2 Yrs Mid Tier 96.1
A. Rodgers Sat 3 Yrs Top 10 101.2
S. Darnold Started Wk 1 Sub-55 77.3
J. Rosen Started Wk 3 Sub-50 66.7
B. Young Started Wk 1 Sub-52 73.7
Export Scouting & Strategy Dossier
Enjoy this tool? Build your own with Super