Running Back Efficiency Lab

Explore workhorse volume, rush gap tendencies, contact evasion, and season-long output models. Built to resolve backfield debates like Kenneth Walker III vs. Jonathan Taylor with real physical metrics.

Prompted by @TheAthletic "Which RB is in line for a better season: Walker III or Taylor?"

Kenneth Walker III Simulation

Click any offensive line gap or tap a button below to trigger live carries.
Ready for kickoff
Interactive: Click on any offensive gap to run ball carrier
Choose Run Concept & Offensive Gap
Projected Rush Yds 1,136 4.32 YPC / 263 att
Projected Rush TDs 9.4 58% Redzone share
Receiving Scrimmage 228 yds 29 rec • 1.1 rec TD
PPR Fantasy / Game 13.8 RB14 Consensus tier

Walker III vs. Taylor Tale of the Tape

Analytical Dimension Kenneth Walker III Jonathan Taylor Simulation Edge
Expected Carries / Game 15.5 carries 19.0 carries Taylor (+3.5 workhorse margin)
Missed Tackles Forced % 27.0% (Elite elusiveness) 21.8% (Power drive) Walker III (+5.2% contact shake)
Yards After Contact / Att 3.25 YCO/A 3.45 YCO/A Taylor (+0.20 push efficiency)
Breakaway Run Rate (15+ yds) 13.5% (High burst) 11.2% (Steady chunk) Walker III (+2.3% home-run upside)
Goal Line / RZ Share 58% SEA backfield 74% IND bellcow Taylor (+16% high-value touches)
OL Run Blocking Support 54.0 (League avg) 68.5 (Top-8 unit) Taylor (Superior trench push)
Simulated 17-Game Total 1,364 scrim yds / 10.5 TDs 1,580 scrim yds / 13.8 TDs Jonathan Taylor (Volume & OL edge)
Simulated Play-by-Play Log Recent carries & defensive collision outcomes
Drive initialized: Select a gap or click 'Simulate Drive' to evaluate reps. --

Why Volume & Offensive Line Play Dictate the Verdict

While Kenneth Walker III possesses unmatched sudden acceleration and forced missed-tackle rates (routinely ranking top-5 in elusiveness), Jonathan Taylor benefits from Indianapolis' superior offensive line run-blocking grade and an unchallenged goal-line stranglehold. In the NFL, offensive line push accounts for ~48% of rushing yard variance before contact.

Simulation Physics & Methodology

The simulator projects carries using a combination of offensive line leverage (yards before contact), individual elusiveness (MTF % and YCO/A), and defense box count distributions. Red zone goal-to-go opportunities are scaled against team run-pass ratios in scoring territory.

Enjoy this tool? Build your own with Super